REVIEW: We Fell HARD for This NEW Fudgy Cookie in Magic Kingdom

Some scary good snacks are being cooked up for Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party!

New snacks have arrived!

There are tons of good eats and treats that are exclusive to the special ticketed Halloween party at Magic Kingdom this year. You’ll find different food and beverage items across the park. We stopped by Pinocchio Village Haus to try two NEW items, and we’re bringing you our full reaction.

Pinocchio Village Haus has been bringing exclusive eats, treats, and drinks to many Halloween parties, and they have two new items on the spooky menu this year! The quick-service restaurant will be open until 10 PM during party nights. This year, you can enjoy two brand-new items on the menu that will only be available during Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party. That includes the Fra Diavolo Chicken Sandwich and the Cruella Cookie Sandwich.

The menu!

The first thing we grabbed was the Fra Diavolo Chicken Sandwich for $13.99. This is fried chicken breast with fra diavolo sauce, cheese, basil pesto, and arugula on a ciabatta bun, served with french fries.

Fra Diavolo Chicken Sandwich

This was a surprising win at the party! Before trying it, we thought it would be pretty dry and stale based on how it looked. The bread had a perfect crunch on the outside while being really soft and airy on the inside. The herbs and the Parmesan on top of the bread add a ton of flavor. The Parmesan is mild and familiar, but still tasty.

Here it is!

The chicken was moist and not dry at all. The breading was forgettable, but still pleasant. We wish the arugula was there a little bit more because it added a really nice light pepper flavor. The cheese and the basil pesto were almost nonexistent.

A look at the chicken and toppings

The main flavor is the marinara sauce, which had a slight kick to it. If you’re super spice-versed, you should not get this! It’s really subtle, and definitely Disney spicy. It surprised us, so it might surprise some other people. The sauce was fresh and has a really nice balance of sweet and acidic tones. It melts into the bread, making the bread so flavorful, even though it’s a little bit soggy. It’s not gonna knock your socks off; it’s not gonna blow your mind, but this is a good, decent-quality item that we would genuinely get again.

It’s not that bad!

Then we tried the Cruella Cookie Sandwich for $6.29. This is chocolate cookies filled with raspberry ganache dipped in white chocolate and sprinkles.

Cruella Cookie Sandwich

Ok, this cookie is what you come to Pinocchio Village Haus for! We are officially obsessed with this, and we didn’t even anticipate liking it. The cookie is a thick, almost fudgy, chocolate chip cookie. It has the nicest chewy element, but it’s not gummy, and it’s not too soft.

This is so tasty!

It’s almost like a brownie that’s just baked enough not to fall apart. The ganache is really interesting. We would definitely warn people that this treat will quickly get messy, especially because there’s more of the ganache underneath the cookie to hold it onto the plate. Once you pick it up, it’ll be dirty!

It has such a cute design!

The ganache is really silky and has a really strong sweet flavor. It tastes like a fake raspberry flavor, but not in a negative way. It’s sweet and slightly tart, which balances well with the dark chocolate. We could definitely see this being too sweet for a lot of people, but we’re really enjoying it and are pleasantly surprised. It’s moist and flavorful, but definitely messy.

Give it a try!

As we mentioned before, that’s not all you can get at Pinnoccio Village Haus during the party. The following are items that have returned:

Undead Garlic-Parmesan Chicken Strips — with garlic-Parmesan sauce, parsley, and served with french fries.
Scary Ghost Slushy — Blue raspberry slushy with marshmallow foam and a marshmallow ghost (Non-alcoholic)
Phantasmal Fried Pumpkin Ravioli — served with black garlic aïoli and a side Caesar salad

Undead Garlic Parmesan Chicken Strips

We’re going to be trying everything that the Halloween party has to offer. For more food reviews, make sure to follow us at the Disney Food Blog!

These 5 Spots Have the BEST Snacks During Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party in Disney World

Join the DFB Newsletter to get all the breaking news right in your inbox! Click here to Subscribe!

WE KNOW DISNEY.
YOU CAN, TOO.

Oh boy, planning a Disney trip can be quite the adventure, and we totally get it! But fear not, dear friends, we compiled EVERYTHING you need (and the things to avoid!) to plan the ULTIMATE Disney vacation.

Whether you're a rookie or a seasoned pro, our insider tips and tricks will have you exploring the parks like never before. So come along with us, and get planning your most magical vacation ever!

What do you want to try? Let us know in the comments!